Gist Independent
Sharp takes, deeper dives
The everyday, explainedBy Huw Allen

The Ned. Discretion was the product.

A private members club that charges four grand a year for discretion emailed every member at once, with all their addresses showing.

THE GIST ON THE NED: "Discretion Was the Product"

Thumbnail for The Gist on The Ned, titled "Discretion Was the Product".

Watch "Discretion Was the Product": The Gist on The Ned.

What did The Ned do?

The Ned is a private members club in the City of London. Annual fees start at four grand. Last month they emailed all their members about raising the price, a hundred at a time, exposing everyone's email address. Because the discretion was meant to be the product.

What is The Ned?

Soho House for the bowler hat crowd. It opened nine years ago in the Midland Bank building, with rooftop pools, a spa and restaurants inside a Grade I listed vault. Membership costs four grand a year.

The emails went out in batches of a hundred, with every recipient's address visible to all the others. It kept going for weeks. For a club whose product is discretion, that was the entire business model reversed in one send.

Is it just The Ned?

No. In June, a secretive network linked to Peter Thiel had 222 elite members exposed via a source code leak. Soho House had its own breach six years ago. Every luxury members business is running Windows XP grade tech.

What are members really buying?

Four grand buys you access to the pool. What it really buys is access to a list that no one else can see. Until now, and that list is now in every recipient's inbox.

Private banking, wealth management, off-market property, concierge medicine: all built on a promise of discretion their infrastructure risks breaking every day. You can't pay to disappear anymore. Or can you?

Would you leave a club over a data slip?

Your take. One tap, then see how everyone else voted.

Quick answers

What did The Ned get wrong?

It emailed members about a price rise in batches of a hundred with every recipient's address visible to the others, over several weeks.

How much does The Ned cost?

Annual fees start at four grand.

What is the wider point?

Luxury members businesses sell discretion but run weak tech, so you can't pay to disappear anymore.

See you on the next one.

What should the next one be? Suggest a topic for Huw to explain

The conversation

Comments

Nothing here yet. Start the conversation: Huw reads every comment before it is published.

Back to all Gists

Liked that? There's a newsletter every Friday.

One subject, properly, through your letterbox every Friday. Written by people. No rolling news and no outrage. Informed, not overwhelmed.

You're on the round. First one lands on Friday. Check your inbox to confirm.

Free. Unsubscribe whenever you like. Demo only: nothing is sent yet.