Chocolate. The price tells them to look elsewhere.
Nestle now sells chocolate with no cocoa in it, made from fermented sunflower seeds. Cocoa prices have already collapsed, and the substitute does not go away when they do.
THE GIST ON CHOCOLATE: "Chocolate Without Cocoa"
What is cocoa-free chocolate?
Nestle now sells chocolate with no cocoa in it. It's made from fermented sunflower seeds, and it's a permanent product, not a trial. Mars is testing its own, and cocoa prices have already collapsed, because the substitute doesn't disappear when the price comes back down.
Why did cocoa prices spike?
In 2022, cocoa was about $2,000 a tonne. By the end of 2024, it had hit $13,000, six times the price. The reason had been brewing for decades.
West Africa grows roughly two thirds of the world's cocoa on roughly 2.5 million small farms. Those farmers have been paid so little for so long that they were never able to replant. The trees that exist are 25 to 40 years old, diseased, and yields have fallen away.
How does sunflower chocolate work?
Raw cocoa is revolting: bitter and astringent. Everything you love about it comes afterwards, from fermenting the beans for a week and roasting them. A German company does the same process with sunflower seeds, and the product is so close to chocolate that Nestle is rolling it out in Germany and Mars is trialling another.
Who lost out?
The shortage did benefit the farmers. Ghana and the Ivory Coast set the price their farmers are paid, and during the spike it went up by 50%, so they were finally well compensated. Then the factories started buying less, demand dropped and the price crashed to $2,000.
And surprise, surprise, the farmers are getting screwed again. The one time they get paid close to what the crop is worth is the same time their customers go in search of an alternative. That is what a high price really does: it tells whoever's buying to go and find another way.
Would you eat cocoa-free chocolate?
Your take. One tap, then see how everyone else voted.
Quick answers
What is Nestle's cocoa-free chocolate?
Chocolate made from fermented sunflower seeds, a permanent product rather than a trial. Mars is trialling its own.
Why did cocoa prices rise?
Farmers in West Africa, who grow about two thirds of the world's cocoa, were paid so little they could not replant, so trees aged, got diseased and yields fell. Prices went from $2,000 a tonne in 2022 to $13,000 by the end of 2024.
What happened to farmers?
Ghana and the Ivory Coast raised farmer prices by 50% during the spike. Then demand dropped and prices crashed to $2,000 again.
See you on the next one.
What should the next one be? Suggest a topic for Huw to explain
The conversation
Comments
Nothing here yet. Start the conversation: Huw reads every comment before it is published.
