Gist Independent
Sharp takes, deeper dives
The everyday, explainedBy Huw Allen

Halloween. No strings attached.

The pumpkin is bought, carved, photographed and thrown away. Huw looks at a ritual whose obligations have faded while its annual shopping list has flourished.

THE GIST ON HALLOWEEN

Thumbnail for The Gist on Halloween, titled "No Strings".

Watch "No Strings": The Gist on Halloween.

What does the supermarket sell?

A pumpkin, a candle and a few decorations turn into a recognisable celebration. The product is more than the vegetable: it is the short-lived experience of taking part, repeated in homes and photographs every year.

What happened to the meaning?

Huw traces a contrast between older customs of remembrance, prayers and cakes, and the modern retail ritual. Stripped of those obligations, the celebration is easier to join and easier to sell. No deeper commitment is required at the checkout.

Why does the purchase have to happen again?

The pumpkin rots, the decorations come down and the next October creates another occasion to buy. Huw's argument is that a tradition passed between generations and a product sold every year reward very different things.

Does this change how you see halloween?

Your take. One tap, then see how everyone else voted.

Quick answers

What does the supermarket sell?

A pumpkin, a candle and a few decorations turn into a recognisable celebration. The product is more than the vegetable: it is the short-lived experience of taking part, repeated in homes and photographs every year.

What happened to the meaning?

Huw traces a contrast between older customs of remembrance, prayers and cakes, and the modern retail ritual. Stripped of those obligations, the celebration is easier to join and easier to sell. No deeper commitment is required at the checkout.

See you on the next one.

What should the next one be? Suggest a topic for Huw to explain

The conversation

Comments

Nothing here yet. Start the conversation: Huw reads every comment before it is published.

Back to all Gists

Liked that? There's a newsletter every Friday.

One subject, properly, through your letterbox every Friday. Written by people. No rolling news and no outrage. Informed, not overwhelmed.

You're on the round. First one lands on Friday. Check your inbox to confirm.

Free. Unsubscribe whenever you like. Demo only: nothing is sent yet.