
The Gist newsletter, issue 34
Let Us Play
Gist Deep Dive #34
Indulgences built St. Peter's, pretend yachts built GTA 6, a museum filled with chairs, and a dead man still sings when you turn for camp.


You can get The Gist on this story here
In 2010, I rode a horse into Mexico. The game was Red Dead Redemption, made by Rockstar, and I had spent 20 hours in it as John Marston, a worn-out outlaw being blackmailed into hunting his old friends. I'd just shot my way across a river on a raft. On the far bank, I climbed onto a horse, pointed it south and let it gallop. A guitar started. Then a voice, José González, a song called Far Away, the first words anyone had sung in the whole game. The desert opened out, the horse kept running, and for 3 minutes I was somewhere ethereal, half inside a film and half inside my own afternoon, on a sofa in England with my heart going.
Watch the video on YouTube (opens in a new tab)
8 years later, Rockstar did it to me again. In Red Dead Redemption 2, you are Arthur Morgan, an enforcer for a gang that is coming apart, and late in the story, he is shipwrecked on an island called Guarma and has to fight his way home. He lands back in America alone, finds a horse, rides to camp, and D'Angelo starts to sing Unshaken. That ride opens the last chapter. By the end of it, Arthur is dying of tuberculosis on a hillside with the sun coming up. I had been him for weeks. The only word I have for what I felt is communion, with a man who never existed and with the thousands of strangers who made him.
Watch the video on YouTube (opens in a new tab)
Yesterday Rockstar released Grand Theft Auto 6. The last one came out in 2013. The reviews average 99 out of 100, tying the highest score any game has ever had, and more than 17m people paid about $1.65bn for it before it even existed in their houses. By last night, Sensor Tower estimates it had taken more than $2bn. I haven't played a minute of it. I've been writing to you. You're welcome.

I can tell you what I've been told. It's a love story. Jason and Lucia are 2 small-time criminals in Leonida, Rockstar's invented Florida, trying to get out of a job that has gone wrong. The Guardian's reviewer, Keza MacDonald, gave it 5 stars and wrote: "I did not expect it to make me so emotional." By the final missions, she felt sick with worry for 2 people made of light. The man from IGN needed nearly 120 hours to reach the credits.

Nothing else we call entertainment is made like this. A film takes 2 or 3 years. This took 13. More than 5,000 people are thanked in the credits of the last one, and you could not name 3 of them. Some estimates put the cost above $1bn, when the most expensive film ever made, Jurassic World: Dominion, cost $658.8m. Thousands of anonymous hands, working for half a generation, on one thing that ordinary people then queue to walk around inside. We have made things this way before, and we called them cathedrals. I think Grand Theft Auto 6 is one, and I am being serious. They’re built by thousands of people nobody will remember, over more years than makes sense, so that the rest of us can walk in and go somewhere else.

Every cathedral ever built comes with the same awkward question. Who paid?
Rockstar used to live the way most of us live. You make a thing, you sell it, the money runs down, and you make another. GTA 3 came out in 2001, Vice City in 2002, San Andreas in 2004. A game earned for 2 or 3 years, and then the studio needed the next one, ready or not.
Then GTA 5 arrived in 2013 with an online mode bolted on, a shared version of the city where you can spend real money on pretend cars, pretend penthouses, and pretend yachts. People have never stopped spending. If you have ever found a few pounds to Rockstar Games on a card statement and blamed a teenager, congratulations, you are a patron of the arts. The GTA business has brought in about $10bn since then, and a decade after launch it was still taking around $170m every 3 months with nothing new on the shelf. Across Take-Two, which owns Rockstar, 82% of last year's $6.72bn came from purchases like these, made inside games people already owned.

My favourite detail is from 2017. Rockstar's director of design, Imran Sarwar, was asked why GTA 5's story had never been given a sequel chapter, and he said they "did not feel single-player expansions were either possible or necessary". For years I read that sentence as a death notice for the thing I loved. Read it again, and it says something much stranger. A studio had found a way to pay its wages without releasing anything, and it used the freedom to disappear for 13 years.

St. Peter's in Rome was paid for, in part, by selling indulgences: real money handed over for something nobody could hold. Martin Luther thought that was a disgrace, said so in 1517 and split a continent. The dome went up regardless, and people still go quiet when they walk in. I spent years producing theatre, and every regional theatre in Britain runs on the same model. The Christmas panto pays for the Spring Pinter. The pretend yachts paid for Arthur Morgan.

The money runs the other way, too. Nobody puts money on a collection plate in a car park, and nobody buys a pretend yacht in a city they don't love. It's the story that makes people love the city. The analysts who follow Take-Two have hardly mentioned Jason and Lucia this week. What they want to know is whether the online mode that comes after them can earn for another decade. Rockstar spent 13 years on a love story so that millions of people would want to stay in Florida once it's over.
What the money bought was time, and every year of it shows up on the screen. Red Dead Redemption 2 took 7 years. It has 500,000 lines of dialogue spoken by 1,200 actors, and its main story runs 60 hours. For all of those 60 hours, you are inside it. You choose whether Arthur helps the widow or robs her. You brush the horse. When the cough starts, it starts in a man you have been steering with your own thumbs for a month. A book can make you grieve for somebody. Only this can make you feel guilty about them, because you were there and you did it. Nobody watches a cathedral. You go in.

What you go in for is the same: to be taken somewhere that isn't here. Abbot Suger, who rebuilt Saint-Denis (pretty apt name) outside Paris in the 1140s and more or less started the Gothic style, wrote that the light through his new windows lifted him out of the ordinary world and set him down somewhere between earth and heaven. Everything in those buildings was arranged to do that: the height, the coloured glass, and above all the organ, a sound so large it seems to come out of the walls. Centuries of it have left a mark on us. When Christopher Nolan wanted cinema audiences to feel they were leaving the planet in Interstellar, Hans Zimmer recorded the score on the 1926 organ of Temple Church in London, and it worked on people who hadn't sat in a pew for years. Somewhere deep down, that symbolised transcendence.

Truly pulling out all the stops.
Rockstar builds the other world outright, a desert, a river and a horizon you can ride to, and then does what the cathedral builders did and brings in the music at the moment you look up. A guitar on a riverbank in an invented Mexico was doing the organ's job. For 60 hours I stopped being a man on a sofa and went somewhere else entirely.
Watch the video on YouTube (opens in a new tab)
Hector, the eccentric teacher in Alan Bennett’s The History Boys, says that the best moments in reading come when you find a feeling you thought was yours alone, set down by a stranger, and it is as if a hand has come out and taken yours. That is one writer finding one reader. These games have no hand to offer. A few people wrote Arthur and several thousand built the mud he rides through, the weather over it and the light on the water, and what reaches you is too large to belong to any of them. The masons didn't sign the stone either. The great ones, both Red Deads and the Polish epic The Witcher 3, feel like stories told from beyond the grave, and one of them now is. D'Angelo died in October 2025, aged 51. The song still starts when you turn the horse for camp.
Videogames Are Not Art. But They Are Important.
It’s fairly common to hear videogame scholars describe videogames as art. In fact, there are whole books and articles arguing that…
Medium • David Dennen
None of this is thought of as art. GTA 6 was reviewed on the games pages and will win no prize my mum has heard of. When the Museum of Modern Art in New York finally let video games through the door, in 2012, it bought 14 of them and filed them under design, with the chairs.
When Video Games Came to the Museum | Magazine | MoMA
A decade ago, MoMA acquired 14 video games, and kicked off a new era for the collection. Today there are 36, and many are in the exhibition Never Alone.
The Museum of Modern Art
Part of the reason is the price of admission: a critic can see a film on a Tuesday night, and nobody on an arts desk has 120 hours. The rest is the signature. Since the Renaissance we have handed greatness to a name, a painter, a novelist, a director, and a work with 5,000 makers gives the judges nobody to hand it to. The cathedrals had the same trouble. Gothic began as an insult. Giorgio Vasari and Italian writers of the 1500s used it to mean the barbarous work of the Goths, and educated Europe looked down its nose at Chartres for most of 300 years.

The rest of the industry has paid for this too. Every other games company looked at Rockstar's arrangement and tried to build its own, and most of them failed, because nobody has room in their life for more than 1 or 2 games that never end. In 2024, Sony released a shooter called Concord, pulled it after 2 weeks, and reportedly lost more than $200m. Shawn Layden, who used to run PlayStation's studios, says the ordinary mid-sized game is finished: "AA is gone." Around 57,000 people have lost jobs in games since 2022. This month the rest of the industry cleared its own releases out of November to stay out of its way.

The money arrives in small amounts from people buying things that don't exist. No comment on the comparison to indulgences. The work is punishing: Dan Houser, who co-wrote both Red Deads, has talked about 100-hour weeks at the end of the second. My mum, who thought games were for children and counted mine as the bane of her life, would point out that 60 hours is a long time to spend on a sofa. She and Luther had a point.
The people who watched Chartres go up never called it art. That word arrived centuries later, from people who had never carried a stone. The ones who were there just went in, on an ordinary morning, stood under something bigger than any of them could have made alone, and felt the top of their head come off. Nobody asked them to explain it.
Yesterday more than 20m people did the same thing, on the same day, all over the world. I can’t think of a bigger congregation.

At Rockstar’s current pace, the next one arrives when I’m 49. Tonight I go in. Somewhere in the next few weeks I’ll be driving through an invented Florida with nowhere to be, a song will start, and I’ll put my foot down to keep up with it, the way I let a horse run in Mexico 16 years ago. Thousands of people I will never meet spent 13 years making sure I would. One day somebody will get round to calling that art. I’m not going to wait for them.
See you on the next one.
References
GTA VI hailed as masterpiece after 13-year wait (Brit Brief, 19 November 2026)
GTA 6 Passes 17 Million Copies Sold And $1.6 Billion In Revenue On Eve Of Launch (GameSpot)
GTA 6 generates estimated $2.36 billion on launch day, sells 24.6 million copies (Ednews)
The most expensive movie ever: Jurassic World Dominion (Fortune, 17 June 2026)
Over 6,000 people worked on Grand Theft Auto (TweakTown)
GTA franchise may hit $10 billion revenue between 5 and 6 (TweakTown)
Rockstar explains lack of GTA 5 DLC (GamesRadar, 24 October 2017)
Red Dead Redemption 2 has a 60-hour story, 500,000 lines of dialogue (GamesRadar, 15 October 2018)
Moments: Welcome to Mexico (Game Informer, 3 December 2012)
Abbot Suger: On What Was Done in His Administration (Fordham Medieval Sourcebook)
Interstellar at 10 (Gramophone, Choir & Organ)
MoMA acquires 14 video games for permanent collection (NBC News)
Why "Gothic" was originally an insult (Mental Floss)
Sony Closes Studio Behind Concord, Which Reportedly Lost Over $200 Million (AV Club)
Ex-PlayStation head says the AA middle ground is gone (GamesRadar, 17 October 2024)
Five years post-pandemic, 57,000 games industry jobs have vanished (Inven Global, 14 October 2026)
GTA 6 Is Forcing the Entire Industry to Move Out of the Way (Beebom)

